Case Highlight: Transfer to Tribal Court

Transfer cases are always high on my list of cases to track. I believe that getting cases out of state court and into tribal court is almost always the best option. There are many barriers to making this happen, but when it can, the barrier shouldn't be the state court itself.
Whew.
There are a number of things about this opinion I wanted to note. The first is how quickly the Tribe moved to intervene. Within the month of the removal, the Tribe moved to intervene. I may be too cynical, but my guess is notice didn't get out THAT quickly. Second, the removal of the child from her parents was certainly suspect, as the Tribe pointed out. Third, the Tribe retained local counsel, and the court did not allow the Tribe's attorney to participate remotely. I've both had some cases where this has happened and continue to hear about it. The financial pressures this puts on tribes to have to fly their attorney and any potential witnesses to a state court is significant, and is also ridiculous in this day and age.
After the child was removed from her parents, she was placed with her paternal grandparents (or rather, the child was already visiting with her grandparents when she was "removed"--as I noted, this was a removal lacking in the evidentiary burden). The agency determined they were "custodians" with a "meaningful right to be heard" under West Virginia law. When the Tribe moved to transfer the case to tribal court, neither parent objected, and the Tribe presented a tribal court order accepting jurisdiction should the state court grant the transfer motion. It appears from the opinion that the grandparents "objected" to the transfer, but did not make a "good cause" motion to deny transfer.
Instead, the state court itself determined there was good cause not to transfer the case for two reasons. The first, that the Tribe had not previously moved to transfer prior proceedings, is explicitly forbidden as a reason to deny transfer by the federal regulations. The second, that everything having to do with the child is in West Virginia, has marginally more weight if the trial court had done an actual analysis rather than a statement. Instead, the court of appeals found that the trial court made no actual findings regarding the Tribal Court as an inconvenient forum. Indeed, the trial court provided no written findings of fact and conclusions of law to any of the Tribe's motions. I cannot stress enough that this is a constant problem with certain state trial courts around the country.
In this case, it was a particular issue because in West Virginia, this appeal was considered "interlocutory," and normally would have required a written order to move through an appeal. However, the court of appeals correctly found that the federal regulations require a written or oral order on the record for a denial of transfer, and that the interests of the Tribe outweigh the court rules/precedent.
The court of appeals not only overturned the lower court, but also explicitly directed it to transfer the case to tribal court. This is the correct outcome, but there are a lot of small things here the appellate court could have gone the other way on. I have no doubt the lawyering for the Tribe was great, and some of these issues can be handled in state law or court rules (and in some states are).
For example, a transfer to tribal court ruling should always be a final order subject to appeal. It is a jurisdictional determination that changes the course of the proceeding fundamentally. Under Michigan's court rules, this would be a final order subject to appeal. In West Virginia it was not. Another example includes the standing of the grandparents to object to this transfer. That was dependent on WV state law and their status as a party(?). The court of appeals found that only parents have the right to object to a transfer under ICWA, which is correct. Parties, however, under the federal regulations, have the right to file a good cause motion to deny transfer. Again--state law determines who a party is or is not, and therefore who has a right to file motions and who does not. State ICWA laws AND state court rules can make a huge difference in practice and can lead to fewer appeals.
In any case, I am very much looking forward to being on a panel with the Tribe's attorney in this case later this week at the Tribal In-House Counsel Association annual conference. I hope to ask her to talk about what she can and how they handled the trial level court.