Case Highlight: Dual Burden in Florida

I have been getting a weird number of questions about this opinion out of the Supreme Court of Florida so I'm highlighting it, but only to highlight that it's unremarkable.
The opinion is In the Interest of A.H. & K.W. and the Florida Supreme Court released it late last week. The Court heard it because there was a split in the lower appellate courts between a decision in 2010 and one this year.
I haven't directly touched on this issue in this newsletter yet, though there was an interesting case out of Minnesota I've been covering in my annual case law presentations this year. The question is what state courts must find in an ICWA case to place a child in foster care or terminate parental rights (TPR). For the purposes of this post, we will stick with TPR.
To terminate parental rights under ICWA, the court must meet the standards in 25 U.S.C. 1912(d) and (f):
Any party seeking to effect a foster care placement of, or termination of parental rights to, an Indian child under State law shall satisfy the court that active efforts have been made to provide remedial services and rehabilitative programs designed to prevent the breakup of the Indian family and that these efforts have proved unsuccessful.
and
No termination of parental rights may be ordered in such proceeding in the absence of a determination, supported by evidence beyond a reasonable doubt [BARD], including testimony of qualified expert witnesses, that the continued custody of the child by the parent or Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child.
No state has the beyond a reasonable doubt standard in their state law outside of a state ICWA law (as far as I am aware). However, all states have state law standards for termination of parental rights. In Florida, the state must meet a clear and convincing (C&C) evidence standard that a state statutory ground exists for termination, that it is in the child's best interest, and is the least restrictive means to protect the child from serious harm. I would say this is, on average, pretty representative of state law. The FL Supreme Court claims this is a higher standard for "Indian families" which ... I mean, debatable certainly, given the difference between clear and convincing versus beyond a reasonable doubt, though I suppose I could see an argument where proving up a statutory requirement enhances ICWA's standards.
This doesn't matter, however, because the Florida court requires BOTH the state standards under C&C and the ICWA requirements under BARD to be met for a court to terminate parental rights.
Below, the Sixth District correctly affirmed the circuit court’s application of the relevant evidentiary burdens: clear and convincing evidence for the Florida law findings and beyond a reasonable doubt for the finding required by section 1912(f) of theICWA.
This is the majority position in the states. The 2010 court of appeals case in Florida held that all the elements must be proven under a BARD standard--which while I appreciate very much, is the minority position (I'm actually not aware of any state that requires meeting ICWA's BARD standard for all of the state requirements).
More interestingly to me is the Minnesota case, which says if a court meets ICWA's standard for TPR, then it has necessarily met the state's best interests test since "It is in no child’s best interest to be returned to a home where it 'is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child.'"
Anyway, like I said, a lot of words to let you know this is a pretty unremarkable decision in the ICWA world.